Home Forums Devon Corbel carvings in Exeter Cathedral

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #14841
    OwlHoot
    Participant

    Hi everyone. Those of you interested in church architecture or history (or Devon, although I guess that goes without saying if you are reading this!) may be interested in a blog post I published a couple of months ago on the identities of some corbel carvings in Exeter.

    https://highranges.com/2021/03/16/dual-identities-of-some-exeter-cathedral-carvings/

    The Wikipedia article on William the Conqueror says “No authentic portrait of William has been found”. As you’ll see from the article, I reckon that is wrong.

    #14934
    JM
    (admin)

    Hi OwlHoot. We have had a response to your blog post from Diane Walker, volunteer researcher at Exeter Cathedral. It can be read at https://devonassoc.org.uk/devoninfo/some-exeter-cathedral-nave-corbels-2021/

    #14937
    OwlHoot
    Participant

    Wow, that is astonishing! If you read this Diane, very many thanks for the time and effort you spent in producing your detailed report. I’ll amend my original blog post to include a link to it, as it is only fair readers should see all the evidence pro and con, and I have no axe to grind in presenting only mine such as it is!

    It will take a while to assimilate and consider all the facts and arguments you present. A few I think are debatable, but on the whole there’s no denying the overall conclusion that my conjecture is somewhat less likely (well perhaps a lot less so) than I fondly imagined! But in due course I’ll make a new blog post in reply.

    One implied critique, namely that the comparisons between the two lots of (claimed) identities were somewhat one-sided, can be explained by the overriding need to keep the blog post as short and focused as possible! But I’ll resist the temptation to discuss other points here.

    Two things are especially amazing, one how much the pre-painted carvings differ from their appearance with a new lick of paint, and the other how several blatant typos could remain when I must have read over my blog post a dozen or more times!

    Also, Diane, although I quite understand if you would prefer to not to publish your email address, if I would like to reproduce in the new blog article mentioned above any of the images in your report, is there a general cathedral email address I can use to request permission?

    Regards

    John R Ramsden (jhnrmsdn@yahoo.co.uk)

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.